Monday, November 16, 2009

Here are the top 3 martial arts!! Good research?

Muay thai


Hapkido


wing chun

Here are the top 3 martial arts!! Good research?
VERY GOOD!!





You actually spelled them correctly.
Reply:And what exactly did you base these conclusions on? Anyone can pick three random things and say they're the best in their class.
Reply:Hmm... Neither of those combine too well. May Muay Thai and Hapkido will be okay but... I wouldn't count on it.





Wing chun with anything else is a big no no!





Plus what if someone take you down? Those will be useless and you'll be laying perfectly still as you get a free dental job done.
Reply:First off, there is no best in martial arts, it's like a game of rock-paper-scissors. Just because rock beats scissors doesn't mean it's best, paper comes along and beats it.





Muy Thai is a very hard physical art and it's both very violent and very effective. However, it is also prone to student injury. In real Muy Thai training you are hitting hard wooden object to practice and to harden your limbs. This means a lot of broken bones though. Later on in life that adds up to some crippling damage done to your body. Just look at the old Muy Thai instructors, old in Muy Thai is anything over 50. Other arts get much more longevity out of their instructors because they can still do their arts into their 90's.





Hapkido is very good, very effective art. However, I've seen it beaten by JuJitsu, BJJ, Jeet Kun Do, and Shaolin Chuan Fa (Kung Fu).





Wing Chun focuses on speed rather then hard hits and is a really good art for street fighting, especially if you're not built like an athlete. However, it focuses heavily on hand use and leaves kicking training almost as an afterthought. This leads many students to get incomplete training until they have almost mastered the art.
Reply:A statement like that is meaningless unless you document your standards, specifications, data and data source/s.





In other words: What is your JUSTIFICATION for that statement?


.
Reply:Thats a load of crap. Who told you that ???
Reply:American Boxing


Muay thai


Jiu Jitsu





if i had to pick 3, that's what i'd pick.





P.S. - Dont say American Boxing isn't a martial art, because it is.
Reply:That is your opinion. But, you know what they say. Opinions are like a**holes. Everyone has one and most of them stink. How did you research that? I'm sure many other martial artists would argue those findings.
Reply:I prefer Okinawan karate-do myself
Reply:Yeah that sounds about right, muay thai, well thats kickboxing,hapkido=jujutsu, and wing chun well thats just another rendition of irish boxing. the style doesnt make the man the man makes the style.
Reply:All I can say is that if that is your assesmet, and you truly believe that then your right. I, myself, would not choose those three but if you have experience with the three and have used them in practical application and they work. Then your right , for you. Don't let anyone try to alter your view if you believe this to be true. (of course I will assume you have experience and practical application with those three systems)


No comments:

Post a Comment